Skip to main content

Heterogeneous Spectacles

Aeschylus Danaids at the Pulgas Water Temple

At 4:45pm on November 16th, 2018, a cold, gray, 54 degree afternoon, we staged the two remaining fragments of AeschylusDanaids at the Pulgas Water Temple in San Mateo County.

Let me be clear about what we’re dealing with here: Aeschylus’s Danaids trilogy is mostly gone. Lost to time, fire, neglect, pick your poison. What survives is The Suppliants and a handful of fragments. Tantalizing scraps. We performed two of them.

Fragment 44: Aphrodite’s speech. Seven lines celebrating the universal power of love and desire in nature, how even divine forces drive unions, how the sky desires to penetrate the earth, how everything in the cosmos is basically horny. Beautiful stuff. Cosmic.

And then there’s Fragment 43: the wedding night massacre. The morning after. Fifty bridegrooms, dead by their brides’ hands. The Danaids, who killed their husbands rather than submit to forced marriage. Disobedience to their father Danaus. Defiance of the gods’ will for union. Blood on the sheets instead of the expected kind.

The contrast is the whole point. Love’s creative power versus its violent rejection. Aphrodite’s hymn to desire set against a bride with a knife.

This is part of IOTA, a project with a premise that sounds either brilliant or completely unhinged depending on your blood alcohol level: bring back to life, with site specific performances, every surviving fragment of the lost plays of Aeschylus, Sophocles, and Euripides. The stuff that didn’t make it. The bits and pieces.

Fifteen minutes. Five people, maybe six, depends on whether you count the creepy guy who might have just been waiting for someone.

Here’s the thing: this isn’t my first time at the Pulgas Water Temple. Years earlier, back when I was an undergraduate at Stanford, ambitious, probably insufferable, I wrote an adaptation of the Japanese Noh play Aya no Tsuzumi. Chris Salter, another mentee of Carl Weber, absurdly talented, directed. So there’s a symmetry to it, I guess.  Same impulse to make something beautiful and strange happen in a place most people just drive past on their way to somewhere else.

Aeschylus Danaids, Pulgas Water Temple, site specific theater, tragedy, site responsive theater

The Fragments:

And then will come the brilliant light of the sun, I will graciously awake the bridal couples, enchanting them with song with a choir of youths and maidens.

APHRODITE: The holy Heaven passionately desires to penetrate the Earth, and passionate desire takes hold of Earth for union with Heaven. Rain falls from the brimming fountains of Heaven and makes Earth conceive, and she brings forth for mortals grazing for their flocks, cereals to sustain their life, and the fruit of trees: by the wedlock of the rain she comes to her fulfilment. Of this, I am in part the cause.

The Location:

The Pulgas Water Temple is a monument to one of those massive, hubristic infrastructure projects that could only happen in America. The Hetch Hetchy Project: 160 miles of engineered ambition dragging water from the Sierra Nevada Mountains all the way to the Bay Area. Twenty-four years of construction, straight through the Great Depression. $102 million, which in 1934 money is, well, an obscene amount.

Above the columns, there’s a frieze that reads: “I give waters in the wilderness and rivers in the desert, to give drink to my people.” Biblical. Grand. The kind of thing you inscribe when you’re trying to make flooding a pristine valley sound like divine providence.

William Merchant designed it in the Beaux Arts style, he studied under Bernard Maybeck, the guy who gave us the Palace of Fine Arts. So Merchant knew his stuff. He went with fluted columns, Corinthian capitals, the whole Classical greatest hits package. A love letter to the Greeks and Romans, whose engineering tricks they were basically stealing to pull off this modern miracle of plumbing.

And then there’s Albert Bernasconi, master stone carver, the guy who actually made it real. Who took Merchant’s drawings and turned them into something you could touch. The craftsman. Because that’s how these things work, architects get the credit, but it’s the Bernasconis of the world who do the backbreaking labor of making dreams solid.

Aeschylus Danaids, Pulgas Water Temple, site responsive theater, site specific theater, Tonyanna Borkovi

Collaborators:

I did this with Tonyanna and Ryan, collaborators who get it, who understand that sometimes the most meaningful work happens for almost no one, in the cold, at a monument most people drive past without a second thought.

Dead Tech at the Boat Launch: Palo Alto’s Last Honest Phone

Look at this beautiful goddamn relic. A payphone. At a boat launch in Palo Alto, ground zero for the tech apocalypse that murdered these things.

There’s something almost obscene about it standing there, isn’t there? This monument to a slower, dumber, better world. Back when “faith backed by dollars” meant stringing copper wire across America instead of harvesting our souls for ad revenue.

General Telephone Systems believed in the future. They built things. Actual things you could touch, that worked, that connected human voices across impossible distances. It was infrastructure as religion, and we bought it.

Now? We’ve got phones that fit in our pockets, sure. We’ve got connectivity that would make those GTE engineers weep with joy. But we also can’t make a call without seventeen apps tracking where we are, what we’re buying, who we’re fucking.

This payphone doesn’t care. It just stands there, rusting quietly by the water, a tombstone for an America that believed putting up telephone poles was an act of faith. Maybe it was naive. Probably was.

But shit, at least it was something you could see.

Palo Alto, Boat Launch, telephone, payphone, obsolete technology Palo Alto, General Telephone Systems history

FAITH…
Backed by dollars

When you see telephone lines going up, you see proof your telephone company believes
in the future of your community. General Telephone System has invested hundreds of millions
of dollars in that faith to bring modern telephone communication
to the areas we serve. As we continue to expand and improve our service, thousands
of Americans show their faith by investing their savings in our System;
many others by investing their careers, some by doing both.
It is faith and partnership like this that keeps America great.

GENERAL TELEPHONE SYSTEMS
One of America’s Great Telephone Systems

The Voice from the 10th Row

The great ones don’t teach you a damn thing. Not directly. They just sit there in the tenth row and call out the truth until you stop flinching.

Page 55 of TDR: The Drama Review, Fall 2018 (62:3, T239), featuring the article 'The Voice from the 10th Row: Carl Weber and the Berliner Ensemble,' an interview by Branislav Jakovljević, Keara Harman, Michael Hunter, Jamie Lyons, Lindsey Mantoan, Ljubiša Matić, Ciara Murphy, Jens Pohlmann, Ryan Tacata, and Giulia Vittori. The page includes a black and white archival photograph captioned 'From left: Wolfgang Pintzka, Helene Weigel, and Carl Weber, Berliner Ensemble, 12 May 1960,' courtesy of the Bertolt Brecht Archive.

Carl Weber sat in that tenth row for Brecht. He sat in it for Kushner. He sat in it for me. The man watched the most radical reinvention of performance in the twentieth century from arm’s length, absorbed it into his bones, then spent the next sixty years transmitting that frequency to anyone wired to receive it. Not as doctrine. Never as doctrine. As voltage.

We recorded those interviews, a whole group of us at Stanford, pulling stories out of Carl like archaeologists brushing dust off something irreplaceable. The article lives in TDR now, all properly formatted and academically housed. But a lot of great stuff got left out. That’s the price you pay when you’re serving another master, when the work has to fit the container the institution gives you. The best stories, the ones that made the room go quiet, the ones where Carl’s voice dropped low when he talked about Brecht’s obsession with props looking used, looking real, those don’t always survive the editorial process. The way silence worked differently around him, like he’d learned it from someone who understood that what you withhold is the art. That’s not the kind of thing you can footnote.

He told me once I’d have a life in this. I told him he was crazy. He was right.

What Carl understood, what Brecht understood before him and what the best of us are still trying to articulate, is that the machinery of storytelling isn’t separate from the human thing. The gears and pulleys, the alienation effects and the fourth wall demolitions, all of it exists in service of one brutal, beautiful objective: making people see. Not watch. See.

That voice from the tenth row never stops carrying. Even now. Especially now.

Anna Halprin’s Planetary Dance at the De Young

The Planetary Dance by Anna Halprin in 1980 was created as a call to enact a positive myth in dance. “The Planetary Dance is a dance that transcends cultural and temporal barriers, a dance that speaks to the community that makes it, and a dance that addresses contemporary issues as they are experienced by all people on this planet… It has a purpose: to make peace; it is a dance of peacemakers, a dance that makes peace with itself, makes peace between the performers, makes peace with the sprit, and ultimately makes peace with the earth. The 31st year of the Planetary Dance is a time of crisis on many fronts so we are dancing with ‘life on the line’. A call for healing the economic turmoil, ongoing wars, climate change and many other problems that are threatening our planet .” Anna Halprin

Anna Halprin, De Young Museum, San Francisco Dance, Dance Photography, Leica, Live Art

Anna Halprin, De Young Museum, San Francisco Dance, Dance Photography, Leica, Live Art

Anna Halprin, De Young Museum, San Francisco Dance, Dance Photography, Leica, Live Art

Anna Halprin, De Young Museum, San Francisco Dance, Dance Photography, Leica, Live Art

De Young Museum, San Francisco Dance, Dance Photography, Leica, Live Art

San Francisco Dance, Dance Photography, Leica, Live Art

Anna Halprin, De Young Museum, San Francisco Dance, Dance Photography, Leica, Live Art

Anna Halprin, De Young Museum, San Francisco Dance, Dance Photography, Leica, Live Art

De Young Museum

Anna Halprin, De Young Museum, San Francisco Dance, Dance Photography, Leica, Live Art

Anna Halprin, De Young Museum, San Francisco Dance, Dance Photography, Leica, Live Art

Anna Halprin, De Young Museum, San Francisco Dance, Dance Photography, Leica, Live Art

Anna Halprin, De Young Museum, San Francisco Dance, Dance Photography, Leica, Live Art

Anna Halprin, De Young Museum, San Francisco Dance, Dance Photography, Leica, Live Art

Anna Halprin, De Young Museum, San Francisco Dance, Dance Photography, Leica, Live Art

De Young Museum, San Francisco Dance, Dance Photography, Leica, Live Art

Anna Halprin, De Young Museum, San Francisco Dance, Dance Photography, Leica, Live Art

Making a peace dance, like making peace, is not a small task. It takes the harmony of many to stop a war that only a few might begin. So our peace dance needs the willing commitment of more than two or ten, or twenty, or even fifty performers.

I am seeking one hundred performers—one hundred performers to create a circle large enough for clear images of peace to come through; one hundred performers to create a spirit voice strong enough so that our peaceful song is heard and our peaceful steps are felt.
Anna Halprin

Anna Halprin Planetary Dance
at the De Young Museum, San Francisco

Anna Halprin Rehearsal: Planetary Dance at the De Young

Our culture is in the throes of crisis:
I have a vision of dance working in the service of healing.
I invite you to join me in this quest.
Anna Halprin

I caught something most people can’t see even when they’re staring right at it. Not the performance, fuck the performance, anyone with a decent camera can shoot a performance. I caught the moment before the lie becomes necessary, when these bodies are still figuring out what story they’re supposed to tell.

Anna Halprin, Planetary Dance, De Young Museum, San Francisco Dance, site specific dance, ritual, dance photography, Leica, Dohee Lee

The black and white isn’t an aesthetic choice.  Strip away the color and you strip away context, what’s left is just bodies outside the museum trying to conjure something real while the institution looms behind them.

Anna Halprin, Planetary Dance, De Young Museum, San Francisco Dance, site specific dance, ritual, dance photography, Leica, Dohee Lee

Halprin’s talking healing and I’m there with my Leica like a war correspondent at a séance. I knew what I was after: not the polished thing, not the myth, but the actual labor of people reaching for each other in circles that probably felt ridiculous until they didn’t. Outside, in the weather, in the actual air, not sanitized by the museum’s climate control, but exposed.

Anna Halprin, Planetary Dance, De Young Museum, San Francisco Dance, site specific dance, ritual, dance photography, Leica, Dohee Lee

The fact that it’s a rehearsal matters. The fact that it’s outside matters more. They’re not performing for the institution’s blessing, they’re working something out in the open, trying to figure out if communal gesture still means anything when everything’s collapsing. Most photographers would’ve waited for the real thing, shot it like it was precious. I love to shot the preparation, the build up.

Anna Halprin, Planetary Dance, De Young Museum, San Francisco Dance, site specific dance, ritual, dance photography, Leica, Dohee Lee

Anna Halprin rehearsal for her Planetary Dance
at the De Young Museum led by Dohee Lee

The Making of an Underground Film

Picture this: Walter fucking Cronkite, the most trusted voice in American living rooms, on New Year‘s Eve 1965, serving up Piero Heliczer’s Venus in Furs with the Velvet Underground grinding through Heroin while Heliczer honks away on saxophone like some deranged angel. On CBS. On network television. Before the ball drops.

This wasn’t some slick counterculture packaging job. This was the real deal, the raw nerve ending of American art exposed on the same channel that brought you The Beverly Hillbillies. Mekas, Brakhage, Warhol with his blank stare and Edie with her silver everything, the whole beautiful freak parade momentarily granted access to Middle America’s consciousness between the pot roast and the champagne.


What CBS accidentally broadcast that night was the sound of everything about to change, the exact moment when the underground was still actually underground, before it became a marketing category. Lou Reed’s deadpan liturgy of junk and transcendence, uncut, uncompromising, absolutely not giving a damn whether Des Moines was ready for it or not.

And that’s the thing, it happened because someone, somewhere in that network decided that truth and weirdness and genuine artistic risk mattered more than comfort. Just for a minute. Just once. Before the bean counters and the moral guardians and the whole calcified apparatus of mainstream culture figured out what they’d done and slammed the door shut again.

That broadcast was a document of the last moment American media accidentally told the truth about what was actually happening in the culture.

Adobe HQ: Croissants in the Machine

San Jose. Adobe headquarters. Glass and steel rising from the valley floor like some techno optimist’s Burning Man epiphany. I get it, these places aren’t designed for humans, not really. They’re designed for productivity, for synergy, for whatever Stanford or Harvard MBA horseshit makes shareholders tingle.

But shit, inside these towers, people are actually making something.  I’m not talking about apps and software that help you hide your middle age man boobs.  It’s food.  Outstanding food. Better than these code monkeys deserve, frankly. Mirit Cohen makes sure of that. While the engineers are busy disrupting whatever industry hasn’t been disrupted this week, Cohen’s running a kitchen that would make most restaurants weep. The pastries alone, the pastries. Flaky, buttery, layered perfection that belongs in a Parisian boulangerie, not a corporate cafeteria in San Jose.

This isn’t your standard-issue campus slop. This is real food, made by people who give a shit, for workers who probably don’t even notice between Slack messages and stand-up meetings. These people are eating like kings while staring at pixels. It’s almost obscene.

The irony isn’t lost on me: the best meal some of them will eat all week is free, served on a tray, in a building designed to keep them there as long as possible.

But these, wide-finned in silver, roaring, the light mist of their
propellers in the sun, these do not move like sharks. They move like
nothing there has ever been. They move like mechanized doom.
Ernest Hemingway, For Whom the Bell Tolls

Adobe Headquarters, San Jose, Airplanes,

And that plane overhead, Hemingway’s mechanized doom. it’s passing over people eating croissants that would cost twelve bucks anywhere else.

Silicon Valley, even when it feeds you well, it’s still a gilded cage.

Anna Halprin: Blank Placard Dance, De Young Museum

Anna Halprin Blank Placard Dance: at the invitation of the De Young Museum,   A piece originally performed in 1967 with members of the San Francisco Dancers Workshop in San Francisco as a reaction to the Vietnam War and the growing social unrest of the time.  The dance is a walk by some forty dancers who carry blank placards as they silently move through the streets. The Blank Placard Dance is designed to promote audience participation and active involvement in issues that mattered to people and communities.

“We marched down Market Street carrying placards that were blank, telling people to put their protest on the placard,” Anna explained. “So we didn’t say what the protest was, but people would say, ‘Well, what are you protesting?’ Because it was blank. And we would say, ‘What would you like to protest?’”

Anna Halprin, De Young Museum, San Francisco Dance, Blank Placard Dance, Leica, Music Concourse, Site Specific Dance, Dance Photography, Dance Documentation

Anna Halprin, De Young Museum, San Francisco Dance, Blank Placard Dance, Leica, Music Concourse, Site Specific Dance, Dance Photography, Dance Documentation

De Young Museum

Anna Halprin, De Young Museum, San Francisco Dance, Blank Placard Dance, Leica, Music Concourse, Site Specific Dance, Dance Photography, Dance Documentation

Anna Halprin, De Young Museum, San Francisco Dance, Blank Placard Dance, Leica, Music Concourse, Site Specific Dance, Dance Photography, Dance Documentation

Anna Halprin, De Young Museum, San Francisco Dance, Blank Placard Dance, Leica, Music Concourse, Site Specific Dance, Dance Photography, Dance Documentation

Anna Halprin, De Young Museum, San Francisco Dance, Blank Placard Dance, Leica, Music Concourse, Site Specific Dance, Dance Photography, Dance Documentation

Anna Halprin, De Young Museum, San Francisco Dance, Blank Placard Dance, Leica, Music Concourse, Site Specific Dance, Dance Photography, Dance Documentation

Anna Halprin, De Young Museum, San Francisco Dance, Blank Placard Dance, Leica, Music Concourse, Site Specific Dance, Dance Photography, Dance Documentation

Anna Halprin, De Young Museum, San Francisco Dance, Blank Placard Dance, Leica, Music Concourse, Site Specific Dance, Dance Photography, Dance Documentation

Anna Halprin, De Young Museum, San Francisco Dance, Blank Placard Dance, Leica, Music Concourse, Site Specific Dance, Dance Photography, Dance Documentation

Anna Halprin, De Young Museum, San Francisco Dance, Blank Placard Dance, Leica, Music Concourse, Site Specific Dance, Dance Photography, Dance Documentation

Anna Halprin, De Young Museum, San Francisco Dance, Blank Placard Dance, Leica, Music Concourse, Site Specific Dance, Dance Photography, Dance Documentation

De Young Museum, San Francisco Dance, Blank Placard Dance, Leica, Music Concourse, Site Specific Dance, Dance Photography, Dance Documentation

Anna Halprin, De Young Museum, San Francisco Dance, Blank Placard Dance, Leica, Music Concourse, Site Specific Dance, Dance Photography, Dance Documentation

“The body is living art. Your movement through time and space is art. A painter has brushes. You have your body.”
Anna Halprin

Anna Halprin Blank Placard Dance

Thirty-Five Years, Then This: Common Ground at YBCA

Big name/legendary collaborations are usually a letdown. Two “titans” get in a room together and suddenly everyone’s so fucking precious about their legacy that nothing actually happens, just a lot of careful posturing and committe meeting compromise dressed up in press release language about “exciting new directions” and “boundary-pushing work.”

But thirty-five years? Thirty-five years of near-misses in and around San Francisco before Alonzo King’s LINES Ballet and Kronos Quartet finally locked in? That’s not preciousness. That’s the universe saying wait for it. Because when these two institutions finally shared a stage at YBCA, what emerged wasn’t some diplomatic détente between dance and strings, it was a full-throated conversation about what bodies and instruments can actually say to each other when nobody’s trying to be polite.

The piece opens with water. Not as metaphor-lite or some undergraduate film school symbolism, but water as the thing we can’t escape, the thing that surrounds this impossible peninsula city, the thing that erodes and persists and doesn’t give a damn about your artistic vision. My projections of Sutro Baths, that ruined monument to Victorian excess getting pummeled by the Pacific, set the temperature before a single note or movement. Then the scrim lifts and there’s Kronos in half-shadow, David Harrington and crew turning their strings into percussion, into water droplets, into something beyond the concert hall’s usual reverence. And the dancers respond in Robert Rosenwasser’s wave-curl costumes, all whites and blues and mermaid scallops, moving like they’re underwater but weightless.

Alonzo King LINES Ballet, Kronos Quartet, Common Ground, Yerba Buena Center for the Arts, ballet photography, dance photography, san francisco dance

Common Ground

This wasn’t fusion. This was collision. Forty minutes of bodies carving space while Kronos stomped and plucked through their Fifty for the Future project, music designed to be shared, not hoarded behind intellectual property walls. Everything about this screamed against the commodification impulse, the let’s-monetize-every-note capitalism that’s strangling art. Instead: Commons. Collective resources. The radical notion that not everything needs to be locked down.

Chasing Ghosts: Photographing Alonzo King’s Handel

I’m not going to pretend I understand what Alonzo sees when he makes a ballet, but I know what it feels like to hunt something elusive with a camera, that split second when bodies in motion become something else entirely. Yerba Buena Center for the Arts, October 2018, Alonzo’s remount of his baroque meditation Handel, these LINES dancers aren’t human in the conventional sense, they’re architecture in motion, physics made flesh, extensions that defy the limitations of bone and tendon. The photographer’s dilemma is trying to freeze something that only exists in motion, documenting what was never meant to be still: dramatic level changes, bodies falling and crawling forward, baroque structure meeting contemporary athleticism, Handel’s fugal forms made visible through limbs and torsos. My task was simple and impossible, capture that transcendent moment, preserve what can’t be preserved, make the ephemeral permanent, knowing full well that every photograph is a beautiful lie that tries to remember what it felt like to be in that theater, watching something that existed purely in that moment.

Not just dancers, but devotion.

Not just movement, but meaning.

Chasing Ghosts, Alonzo King Lines Ballet, San Francisco dance, ballet, dance photography, ballet photography, dance documentation, Yerba Buena Center for the Arts, YBCA, San Francisco Art, Handel, ballet dancer, ballerina

The full set of frames from that night, all of it, is here.
Go see for yourself.

×